Thursday, January 27, 2011

Is federation the wrong recipee for Cyprus?


"A solution based on the present talks will be the start of the dissolution of Cyprus -both for Turkish Cypriots and Greek Cypriots.

Under normal circumstances, a federation is created by the mutual agreement of two founding independent sovereign states or provinces, to form one common unitary Federal State - like America and Canada. The said constituent states of a federation, usually possess no powers in relation to foreign policy and therefore, they enjoy no independent status under international law. However, federalism in itself, guarantees equal-representation of member states irrespective of numerical population differences or language. A commitment to form such a system is more than a loose administrative alliance - it’s a marriage without divorce!"

Thu, January 27th 2011 at 19:27
Andreas C Chrysafis comments:

(cnt'd)

Under normal circumstances, a federation is created by the mutual agreement of two founding independent sovereign states or provinces, to form one common unitary Federal State - like America and Canada. The said constituent states of a federation, usually possess no powers in relation to foreign policy and therefore, they enjoy no independent status under international law. However, federalism in itself, guarantees equal-representation of member states irrespective of numerical population differences or language. A commitment to form such a system is more than a loose administrative alliance - it’s a marriage without divorce!

Failure to meet the above criteria - being the fundamental principle of a federation - it would ultimately produce a dysfunctional society without political stability.

Most importantly, one does not use military troops to occupy another nation - like Turkey did in Cyprus - then wily submits to negotiate a pseudo-federation under the pretext of protecting an ethnic minority - as in this case, the Turkish Cypriots! If this proposed “federation” comes into fruition based on the principle that aggressiveness is acceptable and “Might is Right”, it would open up a legal torrent with unforeseeable consequences.

It is wiser for the two communities to negotiate a viable solution between themselves (and kick all the rest out) and try to live as one unified country, one citizenship and one government based on One person - One vote rather than slice the island like a pizza. If this is not reached, Cyprus will be troubled forever and our children and grandchildren will pay the ultimate price for our own stupidity. The choice is ours, so let's stop burning our children on the altar of our own hatred.


Thu, January 27th 2011 at 19:48
ANTIFON comments:

Andreas C Chrysafis, spoken wisely. Unfortunately the majority of real tCypriots are not in Cyprus. We may be hesitant to admit it publicly but the truth is we are debating the Turkish TSK/Ergenekon fascists and their irrelevant puppets (Sampson equivalents, but longer lasting as a result of the occupation).

Only changes in regional geopolitical balance can create the momentum needed to implement the only possible solution: a unitary state. 

All Time Popular Posts

Last 7 Days Popular Posts

Followers

Turkey's Kurds & Cyprus' tCypriots

As either unitary state or federation solutions are discussed as replacements to Cyprus' 1960 and Turkey's 1923 unworkable constitutions, should we abide by "if a right is a right too many for Turkey's Kurdish community (circa 23% of population) then that right is a right too many for Cyprus' tCypriot community too (circa 15%), and vice versa." Is the adoption of this fair logic the catalyst to securing just solutions for both UN countries.